diff --git a/app/Repos/Payment/OnlinePaymentRepo.php b/app/Repos/Payment/OnlinePaymentRepo.php
index 8d9c6db..9b2b171 100644
--- a/app/Repos/Payment/OnlinePaymentRepo.php
+++ b/app/Repos/Payment/OnlinePaymentRepo.php
@@ -194,8 +194,8 @@ class OnlinePaymentRepo
             ]);
         } else {
             $paymentHistory->update([
-                'payer_name' => array_key_exists('cardholderName', $response) ? $response['cardholderName'] : '-',
-                'payer_card' => array_key_exists('Pan', $response) ? $response['Pan'] : '-',
+                'payer_name' => $response['cardholderName'] ?? '-',
+                'payer_card' => $response['Pan'] ?? '-',
                 'paymentStatus' => OnlinePaymentRepo::FAILED,
             ]);
         }